The highest offer for your business is not always the offer that leaves you with the best outcome. Before choosing a buyer, compare how much cash you would receive at closing, what could change that amount, how likely the transaction is to close and what you would be expected to do afterward.
Start With Cash at Closing
Two buyers may quote the same price but offer very different amounts of immediate cash. Ask each buyer to show how the stated value becomes the amount payable to the owners at closing. Debt, cash, transaction expenses and a working capital adjustment may affect that bridge. Do not assume the number at the top of an offer is the amount you will receive.
Separate Certain and Uncertain Proceeds
Put each component of the proposed payment on its own line. Cash paid at closing is different from an earnout tied to future performance. An escrow or holdback may delay access to part of the proceeds. A seller note depends on the buyer making later payments. Rollover equity is an investment whose future value can rise or fall. These amounts should not be treated as interchangeable simply because they add up to the same headline figure.
For example, a $20 million offer with $18 million in cash at closing is not economically identical to a $22 million offer with $14 million in cash and $8 million dependent on future events. The second offer could ultimately pay more, but it also asks the owner to bear more risk. These figures are illustrative, not a valuation of a real transaction.
Ask Whether the Buyer Can Close
Price matters only if the sale closes. Ask how the buyer plans to fund the purchase, which approvals or financing steps remain, what diligence is still required and what could cause the buyer to change the terms. A buyer that appears attractive on price but cannot explain its path to closing may cost the seller time and momentum.
Consider Life After the Sale
An offer is also a proposal for what happens to the company and its owner after closing. Will you need to stay and manage the business? For how long, and with what authority? What does the buyer plan for employees, customers and the company’s operations? The right answer depends on your priorities, but those expectations belong in the comparison alongside price.
Use One Comparison Sheet
A simple side-by-side sheet can prevent the headline number from dominating the decision. For each offer, record the same five answers:
- What is the stated price, and what adjustments may change it?
- How much cash is expected at closing?
- Which payments or investments depend on future events?
- What remains before the buyer can close?
- What role and obligations will the owner have afterward?
Then review the letter of intent against that sheet. It should make the material economics and conditions clear enough to evaluate before you commit to an exclusive process. Your M&A adviser can help compare the commercial proposals; transaction counsel and tax advisers should review the legal documents and after-tax consequences. The best offer is the one that fits your objectives after its price, risk and obligations are understood.