An earnout makes part of a business sale price contingent on performance after closing. For an owner, the headline price is therefore not the same as cash received at closing. The useful question is not simply how large the potential payment is, but what must happen for it to be earned, measured, and paid.
What Is an Earnout?
An earnout is additional consideration payable if agreed post-closing conditions are met. The conditions may refer to revenue, gross profit, EBITDA, customer retention, or another defined measure. It can help bridge a disagreement over future performance, but it also moves some of the seller’s consideration into a period when the buyer controls the business. The structure and risk allocation depend on the actual agreement.
Separate the Price Into Three Parts
Before comparing offers, show the payment components on one page:
| Component | Question for the seller |
|---|---|
| Cash at closing | What is payable immediately after debt, working-capital and transaction adjustments? |
| Deferred but fixed consideration | When is it due, and what credit or security supports payment? |
| Contingent earnout | Which test determines the amount, and who controls the inputs? |
This is a discussion framework, not a valuation formula. A larger possible earnout need not be economically equivalent to the same amount paid at closing.
Five Terms Worth Testing Before Signing
1. The Metric and Its Definition
“Revenue” or “EBITDA” alone is not a complete definition. Specify accounting policies, permitted adjustments, allocation of shared costs, treatment of acquired or diverted customers, and whether the buyer may combine or restructure operations. Ask counsel and the financial adviser to model the wording against actual historical reporting.
2. The Measurement Period
Clarify its start and end dates, treatment of a partial year, and timing of the final calculation. A short period may amplify timing effects; a long period extends uncertainty. There is no universally correct duration.
3. Operational Control
After closing, the buyer may set budgets, pricing, staffing and customer strategy. If those choices can change the earnout result, discuss what operating covenants, information rights and dispute procedures are appropriate. The goal is a workable agreement, not a promise that post-closing performance can be guaranteed.
4. Calculation, Review and Dispute Process
Specify when statements are delivered, what records the seller can inspect, how objections are raised and who resolves accounting disputes. The calculation process deserves attention before a disagreement exists.
5. Employment and Tax Treatment
If an owner must remain employed to receive a payment, ask tax and legal advisers whether any amount might be treated differently from purchase consideration. U.S. installment-sale and contingent-payment rules are fact-specific. The IRS describes a contingent payment sale as one whose total price cannot be determined by the end of the sale year; it also notes separate allocation rules for the sale of a business. Do not assume that every earnout receives the same tax treatment.
A Practical Pre-Signing Worksheet
For each proposed earnout, prepare a low, base and high operating case using internally supportable assumptions. Record the payment produced by the actual draft formula, rather than only the target performance figure. Then identify which variables are under buyer control, what supporting records will remain available, and what happens if the business is sold or reorganized during the period. Label these as scenarios, not forecasts.
Finally, compare the earnout with the rest of the letter of intent, the proposed working-capital adjustment, and findings from quality-of-earnings work. A purchase price is a package of terms, not one number.
Bottom Line
An earnout can be a useful negotiating tool when parties disagree about future results. It is also a contingent claim whose value depends on definitions, control, information and payment mechanics. Owners should have transaction counsel and tax advisers review the exact language before relying on a headline amount.
Pingback: How to Compare Offers When Selling a Business - M&A Done Right
Pingback: Seller Financing in a Business Sale: Key Terms and Risks - M&A Done Right